Combustion analysis is a laboratory technique used to determine the empirical formula of a compound containing carbon, hydrogen, and possibly oxygen (or other elements). By burning a known mass of the sample in excess oxygen and measuring the masses of carbon dioxide and water produced, you can calculate the moles of carbon and hydrogen in the original sample. If the compound contains oxygen, its mass is found by difference. This guide walks you through the procedure, calculations, and common pitfalls.
Formula
The core of combustion analysis is converting the measured masses of combustion products back to the masses of the elements in the original sample.
For carbon: mass of C = mass of CO₂ × (atomic mass of C / molar mass of CO₂)
For hydrogen: mass of H = mass of H₂O × (2 × atomic mass of H / molar mass of H₂O)
If the compound contains oxygen, its mass is: mass of O = mass of sample − mass of C − mass of H
Then convert each mass to moles by dividing by the atomic mass, and divide all mole values by the smallest to get the empirical formula ratio.
Variables:
- m – mass of the original sample (g)
- mCO₂ – mass of carbon dioxide collected (g)
- mH₂O – mass of water collected (g)
- MC = 12.011 g/mol, MH = 1.008 g/mol, MO = 15.999 g/mol
- MCO₂ = 44.009 g/mol, MH₂O = 18.015 g/mol
Worked Example
Suppose you burn 0.250 g of an organic compound and collect 0.550 g of CO₂ and 0.225 g of H₂O. Find the empirical formula.
Step 1 – Mass of carbon:
mass C = 0.550 g × (12.011 / 44.009) = 0.550 × 0.2729 = 0.1501 g
Step 2 – Mass of hydrogen:
mass H = 0.225 g × (2.016 / 18.015) = 0.225 × 0.1119 = 0.02518 g
Step 3 – Mass of oxygen (by difference):
mass O = 0.250 − 0.1501 − 0.02518 = 0.07472 g
Step 4 – Convert to moles:
moles C = 0.1501 / 12.011 = 0.01250 mol
moles H = 0.02518 / 1.008 = 0.02498 mol
moles O = 0.07472 / 15.999 = 0.004670 mol
Step 5 – Divide by the smallest (0.004670):
C: 0.01250 / 0.004670 = 2.68 → 2.67 (approx 8/3)
H: 0.02498 / 0.004670 = 5.35
O: 0.004670 / 0.004670 = 1.00
Multiplying by 3 to get whole numbers gives C₈H₁₆O₃.
Check with the calculator: using the default values, you get mass C = 0.1501 g, mass H = 0.02518 g, mass O = 0.07472 g, and the ratio 2.67:5.35:1.00, which is consistent.
Assumptions
- The sample is pure and completely combusted.
- All carbon is converted to CO₂ and all hydrogen to H₂O.
- No other elements (like nitrogen or sulfur) are present, or their products are accounted for separately.
- The absorption tubes trap all CO₂ and H₂O without leaking or picking up atmospheric moisture.
- Atomic masses used are the IUPAC standard values.
What You’ll Need
- Combustion apparatus (furnace or tube) with controlled oxygen flow
- Sample boat (ceramic or platinum) and a precise balance (0.1 mg or better)
- Two absorption tubes: one filled with a desiccant (e.g., magnesium perchlorate) for water, one filled with a CO₂ absorbent (e.g., sodium hydroxide on asbestos or soda lime)
- Pure oxygen source with flow regulator
- Desiccator for cooling and weighing absorption tubes
- Known standard compound (e.g., benzoic acid) for calibration
- Calculator or spreadsheet for the arithmetic
Step-by-Step
- Dry the sample – If the compound is hygroscopic, dry it in a desiccator over a suitable desiccant (e.g., phosphorus pentoxide) under vacuum until constant mass.
- Weigh the sample – Accurately weigh 0.1–0.5 g of the sample into a clean, dry combustion boat. Record the mass to 0.0001 g.
- Weigh the absorption tubes – Ensure both tubes are clean, dry, and filled with fresh absorbents. Close them, allow them to equilibrate in the balance case for 10 minutes, then weigh each to 0.0001 g.
- Assemble the apparatus – Connect the oxygen source to the combustion tube, then connect the tube to the water absorption tube, then to the CO₂ absorption tube. Ensure all connections are gas-tight.
- Purge with oxygen – Pass a slow stream of dry oxygen through the system for 5–10 minutes to remove any air or moisture.
- Heat the furnace – Bring the combustion furnace to the required temperature (typically 600–900 °C, depending on the sample). Use a temperature that ensures complete combustion without melting the boat.
- Place the sample in the hot zone – Using a magnetic pusher or a rod, slide the boat into the hottest part of the tube. Continue the oxygen flow.
- Allow complete combustion – Keep the sample in the hot zone for 15–30 minutes, or until no further change in the absorption tubes is observed. The sample should burn to a clean ash (if any) and no black carbon should remain.
- Cool and weigh the tubes – After combustion, disconnect the absorption tubes, close them, cool them in a desiccator for 10–15 minutes, then weigh each again. The mass increase of the water tube gives the mass of H₂O; the mass increase of the CO₂ tube gives the mass of CO₂.
- Record the masses – Subtract the initial tube weights from the final weights to get mCO₂ and mH₂O.
- Calculate the empirical formula – Use the formulas above to find the mass of C, H, and O (if present), then convert to moles and find the simplest ratio.
- Verify with a standard – Run a known compound (e.g., benzoic acid, C₇H₆O₂) under the same conditions to check that your apparatus gives the correct empirical formula.
Common Mistakes
- Not drying the absorption tubes – Moisture from the air will add to the water tube mass, giving a false high hydrogen content.
- Leaks in the system – Any leak will let in atmospheric CO₂ and water, skewing results.
- Incomplete combustion – If the sample leaves a carbon residue, not all carbon is converted to CO₂, leading to a low carbon mass.
- Weighing hot tubes – Weighing before the tubes reach room temperature causes buoyancy errors.
- Using the wrong molar masses – Using 12 instead of 12.011 or 16 instead of 15.999 can introduce small errors.
- Forgetting oxygen in the formula – If the compound contains oxygen, you must subtract the masses of C and H from the sample mass; otherwise you’ll get an incorrect empirical formula.
Tips
- Always run a blank (empty boat) combustion to correct for any residual moisture or CO₂ in the system.
- Use a slow, steady oxygen flow – too fast can blow unburnt particles into the absorption tubes.
- Use a desiccant with a color indicator (e.g., Drierite) so you can see when it needs replacement.
- When weighing, handle tubes with tongs or gloves to avoid transferring oils from your fingers.
- If the empirical formula ratio is not close to whole numbers (within 0.05), recheck your arithmetic or consider that the sample may contain another element.
- For compounds with nitrogen, you’ll need additional traps (e.g., a copper reduction tube) to convert nitrogen oxides to N₂.
Troubleshooting
Carbon mass is too low – Check for incomplete combustion (black residue) or a leak that dilutes the oxygen. Increase furnace temperature or combustion time.
Hydrogen mass is too high – Likely due to moisture in the system or the sample absorbing water. Dry the sample and purge the apparatus longer.
Both CO₂ and H₂O masses are high – Atmospheric contamination; check all connections and use a drying tube on the oxygen inlet.
No combustion occurs – The sample may be refractory. Add a combustion catalyst (e.g., copper oxide) or increase the temperature.
Absorption tube mass decreases – This indicates loss of absorbent or a leak. Replace the absorbent and recheck seals.
Empirical formula doesn’t match expected – Run a standard to calibrate. If the standard gives correct results, the issue is with the sample purity or the presence of other elements.
Frequently Asked Questions
Q: What is the empirical formula?
A: It is the simplest whole-number ratio of atoms of each element in a compound. For example, hydrogen peroxide has the molecular formula H₂O₂ but the empirical formula HO.
Q: Can combustion analysis determine the molecular formula?
A: Only if you also know the molar mass of the compound. The empirical formula gives the ratio; the molecular formula is a whole-number multiple of the empirical formula, determined from the molar mass.
Q: What if my compound contains sulfur or nitrogen?
A: The basic method only works for C, H, and O. For nitrogen, you need a reduction tube to convert nitrogen oxides to N₂. For sulfur, you’d measure SO₂. These require additional equipment and calculations.
Q: Why do I need to subtract the mass of C and H from the sample to get oxygen?
A: Because the combustion products only give you carbon and hydrogen directly. If the sample contains oxygen, it appears in the products as part of CO₂ and H₂O, but you can’t measure it directly. By conservation of mass, the oxygen in the sample equals the sample mass minus the masses of C and H.
Q: How accurate do my weighings need to be?
A> For good results, use a balance with 0.1 mg precision. A 1 mg error in the CO₂ mass can change the carbon percentage by about 0.3% for a 0.2 g sample.
Q: What is the minimum sample size?
A> Typically 0.1 g is enough for a modern micro-combustion apparatus, but larger samples (0.2–0.5 g) give more reliable results with standard equipment.
Related
Formula used
in m | Mass of sample | g | 0.250 | 0 in mco2 | Mass of CO2 produced | g | 0.550 | 0 in mh2o | Mass of H2O produced | g | 0.225 | 0 out mc | Mass of carbon in sample | g | mco2 * 12.011 / 44.009 | 4 out mh | Mass of hydrogen in sample | g | mh2o * 2.016 / 18.015 | 4 out mo | Mass of oxygen in sample (by difference) | g | m - mc - mh | 4 out ratio | Empirical formula ratio (C:H:O) | - | round(mc/12.011,2) : round(mh/1.008,2) : round(mo/15.999,2) | 2
Each line is one input (in, sel, list) or one result (out: label, unit, formula, decimals). How the calculators work
Method: the standard formula for this calculation with the constants and conversion factors written on the page, rounded as each result states. See method and constants, the disclaimer or report an error.
More in this section
- QPP Calculator Canada: How It Works & How to Use It
- PPP Calculator World Bank: How It Works & How to Use It2,000.00
- PPP Calculator: India vs USA Cost Comparison1,000.00 USD
- PPP Calculator USD to INR: How It Works2,335 INR
- PPP Calculator India vs UK: Real Cost Comparison103.63 GBP
- PPP Calculator India vs Dubai: Real Cost Comparison8,954.58 AED