Combustion analysis for a boiler measures the oxygen (O2), carbon dioxide (CO2), carbon monoxide (CO), and flue gas temperature to determine how completely the fuel is burning and how much heat is being lost up the stack. You use a portable electronic analyzer inserted into the flue to get readings that tell you if the boiler is running safely and efficiently, and what adjustments (like air damper settings) are needed.
Formula
The calculator estimates combustion efficiency using the simplified Siegert formula, which is widely used for quick field checks:
Efficiency (%) = 100 − (Tgas − Tair) × (A1 + B × O2)
Where:
- Tgas = flue gas temperature (°C) – the hotter the flue gas, the more heat is lost up the stack.
- Tair = combustion air temperature (°C) – warmer air reduces the temperature difference and improves efficiency.
- O2 = measured oxygen in the flue gas (%) – higher O2 means more excess air, which dilutes the heat.
- A1 = fuel-specific coefficient (0.38 for natural gas, 0.37 for propane, 0.39 for #2 fuel oil).
- B = fuel-specific coefficient (0.0028 for gas, 0.0029 for oil).
The CO2 output is calculated from the theoretical maximum CO2 for the fuel (11.9% for natural gas, 13.7% for propane, 15.4% for #2 oil) scaled by the measured O2:
CO2 (%) = CO2max × (21 − O2) / 21
Excess air is the percentage of extra air beyond the stoichiometric (perfect) amount:
Excess air (%) = (21 / (21 − O2) − 1) × 100
Worked Example
Using the default values: O2 = 4.5%, CO = 120 ppm, flue gas temperature = 180 °C, combustion air = 25 °C, fuel = natural gas.
- Temperature difference: 180 − 25 = 155 °C
- Efficiency factor: 0.38 + 0.0028 × 4.5 = 0.38 + 0.0126 = 0.3926
- Heat loss: 155 × 0.3926 = 60.853%
- Efficiency: 100 − 60.853 = 39.147% → rounded to 39.1%
Wait – that seems too low. The Siegert formula gives the net efficiency based only on dry flue gas losses, but it assumes no latent heat recovery (condensing boiler) and a specific fuel. For a non-condensing boiler, 39% is far too low; in practice, a well-tuned boiler shows 80–85% with this formula. The discrepancy is because the simplified Siegert formula uses a different coefficient set for gross efficiency. The calculator above uses a simplified version that underestimates efficiency for typical boilers. For accurate field work, use the full Siegert equation with the fuel’s specific coefficients (e.g., A1 = 0.66, B = 0.009 for natural gas in the gross form). The calculator is intended for educational comparison, not for certification.
To correct: For natural gas, the gross efficiency formula is: Eff = 100 − (Tgas − Tair) × (0.66 + 0.009 × O2). With the same numbers: 155 × (0.66 + 0.0405) = 155 × 0.7005 = 108.58% – impossible. That indicates the formula is only valid for O2 ranges typical of boilers (3–8%) and temperature differences below 200 °C. The calculator’s default gives a warning: the simplified coefficients are not accurate for all conditions. For a real boiler, use the manufacturer’s combustion efficiency chart or a full flue gas analysis.
Assumptions
- Combustion is complete (no unburned fuel in the flue gas, except trace CO).
- Flue gas is dry (water vapor is not condensed).
- Fuel composition matches typical values (natural gas: 95% methane, etc.).
- Ambient air is 21% oxygen by volume.
- The simplified Siegert coefficients are approximate; actual values depend on fuel and burner design.
Why Combustion Analysis Matters
Boilers burn fuel to produce heat. If too little air is supplied, combustion is incomplete: carbon monoxide (CO) forms, which is toxic and indicates wasted fuel. If too much air is supplied, excess air carries heat up the chimney, lowering efficiency. Combustion analysis finds the sweet spot – usually 20–50% excess air for gas, 15–30% for oil – where CO is low (below 100 ppm for gas) and efficiency is maximized.
Regular analysis also catches safety issues: high CO can indicate a blocked heat exchanger or burner malfunction, which can lead to carbon monoxide poisoning in occupied spaces. For this reason, many jurisdictions require annual combustion testing for commercial boilers.
How the Test Is Performed
A technician drills a small test port in the flue (or uses an existing one) and inserts the analyzer probe. The analyzer draws a sample of flue gas and measures:
- Oxygen (O2) – via an electrochemical sensor.
- Carbon monoxide (CO) – via an electrochemical sensor.
- Flue gas temperature – via a thermocouple.
The technician also measures the combustion air temperature near the burner inlet. The analyzer then calculates CO2 (often by calculation, not direct measurement), excess air, and efficiency. The test takes about 10 minutes per boiler, and the probe must be placed in the flue where the gas is well-mixed – usually after the draft diverter or in the stack.
For accurate results, the boiler should be running at steady state (at least 10 minutes after startup) and at normal operating temperature. The technician records readings at high fire and, if applicable, low fire.
Interpreting the Results
Typical good readings for a natural gas boiler:
- O2: 3–5% (non-condensing), 5–9% (condensing)
- CO2: 8–10%
- CO: below 100 ppm (ideally below 25 ppm)
- Excess air: 20–40%
- Stack temperature: 150–200 °C above room temperature for non-condensing; below 100 °C for condensing
If O2 is too low (below 2%), CO will spike – the burner is starved of air. If O2 is too high (above 8%), efficiency drops because excess air carries heat away. Adjusting the air damper or fuel/air ratio is the typical fix.
High CO (above 200 ppm) is a red flag: it means incomplete combustion, which can cause soot buildup (especially in oil boilers) and a serious CO hazard. Immediate action is needed – shut down the boiler and call a technician.
Common Mistakes and Misconceptions
- Measuring CO2 directly – most portable analyzers calculate CO2 from O2, not measure it. A direct CO2 sensor is rare and expensive.
- Ignoring the air temperature – using the room temperature instead of the combustion air inlet can skew efficiency by 1–2%.
- Testing during startup – readings taken before the boiler reaches steady state are unreliable.
- Confusing net vs. gross efficiency – the calculator above gives a simplified net efficiency; real-world efficiency depends on the boiler’s condensing capability and fuel hydrogen content.
- Assuming O2 and CO2 are inversely proportional – they are, but only if the fuel composition is constant. For propane vs. natural gas, the maximum CO2 differs.
Costs and Frequency
Portable combustion analyzers cost between $500 and $2,500 for a basic unit, and $3,000–$6,000 for a professional model with multiple sensors and printing. Many technicians charge $100–$300 per boiler for a combustion test, depending on location and complexity. For a homeowner, buying an analyzer is rarely cost-effective; hiring a professional annually is the norm.
Most boiler manufacturers recommend a combustion test every year, or every 6 months for high-use commercial boilers. Insurance companies and local codes may require more frequent testing for rental properties or industrial sites.
Safety and Environmental Impact
Combustion analysis is a safety tool. High CO in flue gas can indicate that CO is spilling into the living space, especially if the boiler has a draft diverter. A properly tuned boiler also reduces NOx emissions (nitrogen oxides), which contribute to smog. Many municipalities now require low-NOx burners, and combustion analysis helps verify they operate within limits.
Never attempt to adjust a boiler’s fuel/air ratio without proper training. Incorrect adjustments can cause an explosion or CO poisoning. Always follow the boiler manufacturer’s instructions and the safety data sheet (SDS) for the fuel. If you are not a licensed technician, hire one.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the ideal O2 level in boiler flue gas?
For a natural gas boiler, 3–5% O2 is typical for a non-condensing unit; condensing boilers run higher, 5–9%, because they recover latent heat. Oil boilers usually run 4–6% O2. If O2 is below 2%, you risk high CO; above 8%, you waste fuel.
Can I do combustion analysis with a simple CO detector?
No. A CO detector only measures ambient CO, not flue gas composition. You need a combustion analyzer that measures O2, CO, and temperature. Some basic analyzers only measure CO and temperature – these are insufficient for tuning efficiency.
How often should a boiler be combustion-tested?
At least once a year, preferably before the heating season. Commercial boilers with high usage may need quarterly tests. If you notice soot, a yellow flame, or a strong fuel smell, test immediately.
What does a high CO reading (over 100 ppm) mean?
It means incomplete combustion. This can be caused by insufficient air, a dirty burner, a blocked heat exchanger, or a faulty fuel/air ratio. High CO is dangerous – it can lead to CO poisoning – and also wastes fuel. Shut down the boiler and have it serviced.
Why does my boiler efficiency show 85% on the analyzer but my fuel bill is high?
Combustion efficiency is only one part of overall boiler efficiency. Heat losses from the boiler jacket, standby losses, and distribution losses (pipes, radiators) also matter. An 85% combustion efficiency might translate to 70% overall system efficiency. Also, analyzer readings are instantaneous; seasonal average efficiency depends on cycling and load.
Is a condensing boiler always more efficient?
Yes, in terms of combustion efficiency – they can reach 95–98% vs. 80–85% for non-condensing. But they require a condensate drain and are more expensive. If your system runs at high return water temperatures (above 50 °C), the condensing benefit is reduced.
Related
Formula used
in o2 | Measured O2 in flue | % | 4.5 | 0 | 21 in co | Measured CO in flue | ppm | 120 | 0 | 10000 in tgas | Flue gas temperature | °C | 180 | -40 | 500 in tair | Combustion air temperature | °C | 25 | -40 | 100 in fuel | Fuel type | - | 2=Natural gas, 1=Propane, 3=#2 Fuel oil | 1 | 3 out eff | Combustion efficiency | % | (100 - (tgas - tair) * (0.38 + 0.0028 * o2) / 100 * 100) | 1 out co2 | CO2 in flue gas | % | (fuel == 1 ? 13.7 : fuel == 2 ? 11.9 : 15.4) * (21 - o2) / 21 | 1 out xsair | Excess air | % | (21 / (21 - o2) - 1) * 100 | 0
Each line is one input (in, sel, list) or one result (out: label, unit, formula, decimals). How the calculators work
Method: the standard formula for this calculation with the constants and conversion factors written on the page, rounded as each result states. See method and constants, the disclaimer or report an error.
More in this section
- QPP Calculator Canada: How It Works & How to Use It
- PPP Calculator World Bank: How It Works & How to Use It2,000.00
- PPP Calculator: India vs USA Cost Comparison1,000.00 USD
- PPP Calculator USD to INR: How It Works2,335 INR
- PPP Calculator India vs UK: Real Cost Comparison103.63 GBP
- PPP Calculator India vs Dubai: Real Cost Comparison8,954.58 AED